Gabriella's Old Time Pizza

Enjoy authentic Italian flavors at Gabriella's Old Time Pizza in Gas City, IN. Indulge in delicious thin crust pizza, stromboli, breadsticks, and more with outdoor seating. Call +1 765-573-6033 today!

View MenuMake a Reservation

Welcome to Gabriella's Old Time Pizza

Taste the Difference.

Gabriella's Old Time Pizza
Gabriella's Old Time Pizza
Gabriella's Old Time Pizza
Gabriella's Old Time Pizza

Nestled in the heart of Gas City, Gabriella's Old Time Pizza offers a slice of nostalgia. This cozy spot invites guests to indulge in classic Italian comfort food with a twist. Signature dishes like the stromboli and Hawaiian pizza burst with flavors that remind you of Sunday dinners at Grandma's. With a variety of options like hand-tossed crust and bold sauce, there's something to please every palate. Whether you're grabbing a quick lunch or dining with friends on a Friday night, this restaurant is always humming with good cheer and great aromas. Don't forget to save room for the decadent breadsticks!

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

120 E Main St, Gas City, IN 46933, United States

Phone

+1 765-573-6033

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Gabriella's Old Time Pizza
Gabriella's Old Time Pizza
Gabriella's Old Time Pizza
Gabriella's Old Time Pizza

Gabriella's Old Time Pizza has become a beloved fixture in Gas City, Indiana, not just for the food but for its community spirit. From its humble beginnings, this eatery focuses on quality, freshness, and a warm atmosphere. The team values customer satisfaction, ensuring that every visit feels special. Each dish is crafted with quality ingredients, satisfying both traditional and modern tastes.

With 52 menu items ranging from delectable pastas to finger-licking starters like wings and breadsticks, the options are bountiful.

The restaurant thrives during peak hours, especially on Fridays around 7 PM, where the excitement lures diners in. It's a social hub where friends enjoy evenings filled with laughter and shared plates while watching their favorite sports on TV. Gabriella’s commitment to innovation keeps the menu fresh, with seasonal additions that reflect local flavors.

For those who prefer lighter options, gluten-free crusts are available. Exploring Gabriella's also means discovering community-oriented events and specials that bring people together. Locals often gather to celebrate every little occasion, fostering a welcoming vibe that feels like home. Moreover, the restaurant’s commitment to sustainable practices shows in their sourcing of ingredients and eco-friendly initiatives. Gabriella's isn’t just a place to eat; it’s a cornerstone of the local gastronomic landscape, celebrating the art of pizza making with every slice.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday4-9 PM
  • Wednesday4-9 PM
  • Thursday4-9 PM
  • Friday12-10 PM
  • Saturday12-10 PM

Gabriella's Old Time Pizza stands out with its diverse menu and inviting atmosphere. The restaurant boasts a robust selection of specialty pizzas, including the mouthwatering Bacon Cheeseburger and the Basil Supreme. For sandwich lovers, the Buffalo Chicken Ranch Sub hits the spot, while the meatball sub offers a hearty, comforting option.

The outdoor seating provides a charming space to enjoy your meal with a view of the bustling main street, perfect for a warm evening. With an average price of just $9.82 for a satisfying meal, this place offers exceptional value.

The extensive drink menu includes soothing fountain beverages, keeping diners refreshed. Visitors can also customize their pizzas to match their cravings. Overall, Gabriella's is a great spot for families and friends to gather over delicious food.

Gabriella's Old Time Pizza

The exterior of Gabriella's Old Time Pizza presents a classic charm with its bright signage and inviting façade. Situated at 120 E Main St, patrons are greeted by a warm atmosphere before stepping inside. The outdoor seating area enhances the dining experience, creating a lively vibe perfect for social gatherings. It’s a welcoming space, often filled with laughter and the smell of fresh pizza wafting through the air. On pleasant evenings, sit outside to enjoy a meal al fresco while soaking in the Community's heartbeat. Grab a table early on a Friday night to watch the local scene unfold.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

I've been wanting to try this place for a while, but kept forgetting, then I saw Gabi at my work and it reminded me to order her pizza! The regular crust is thin and a good, crisp texture, not the typical fluffy pizza crust, which is a good thing. I don't like super fluffy pizza lol. I tried both regular marinara and bold and both are super yummy! I also love the garlic butter and she even gave me some breadsticks to try! They are fluffy and seasoned really well, and come with a yummy cheese sauce. I love her food! Best pizza I've had in Indiana! I can't wait to try the thin crust next time. The owner is super sweet and really cool and she makes the food herself! You've got a permanent customer! Thank you so much, Gabi!!!

M
Monica S.

Wow- ate here with my fiance and baby last night, did not disappoint. Gabriella was so kind and made our visit even better, we ate breadsticks, wings, 1/2 chzburger & 1/2 pepperoni pizza AND had to try the meatball sub... everything was so good I cannot speak on just one item. She offers two different sauces and the one she came up with is so good it's changed pizza for me. Seems like a smaller town, hopefully she gets the traffic this place deserves! also super cute place to come in and sit down to eat- loved the atmosphere, rest of the town is tad bit boring.

A
Angela T.

First time here, we were all pleased. All the food was sooooooo delish!!! My favorite was definitely the breadsticks! Which unfortunately I didn't get a picture of them. But A+++++ food, service and atmosphere. If we ever go to Gas City again, will definitely return

M
Maria C.

Good pizza is hard to find in Indiana. I have tried so hard to find it. But Gabriellas is actually really, really good. I got the thin crust, Xtra sauce, well done. It was amazing.

J
Jeremy S.

Ella is the best waitress ever!!! She didn't miss a beat! Serve with a smile, laughter and sass!!! Thanks girl we'll be back the next time we're in town.

C
C.A.

Epic service. Very good food. My favorite restaurant. I got the exact thing I ordered and it was good. - Rivers age 9

A
Alexandria S.